Description Set Profiles: A constraint language for Dublin Core Application Profiles

Creator:	Mikael Nilsson KMR Group, NADA, KTH (Royal Institute of Technology), Sweden
Date Issued:	2008-03-31
Identifier:	http://dublincore.org/specifications/dublin-core/dc-dsp/2008-03-31/
Replaces:	Not Applicable
Latest Version:	http://dublincore.org/specifications/dublin-core/dc-dsp/
Status of Document:	This is a DCMI Working Draft.
Description of Document:	This specification describes an information model and XML expression of a "Description Set Profile" (DSP). A DSP describes structural constraints on a description set, allowing for formal expression of the constraints of a Dublin Core Application Profile.

Introduction
Basic structure
Basic semantics
Usage examples
Description Templates
Statement templates
XML structure
RDF variant
Examples

1. Introduction

The DCMI Description Set Profile specification describes an information model and XML expression of a "Description Set Profile" (DSP). The term description set and the associated concepts used in this specification are defined as in the DCMI Abstract model [DCAM].

A DSP is a way of describing structural constraints on a description set. It constrains the resources that may be described by descriptions in the description set, the properties that may be used, and the ways a value surrogate may be given.

A DSP can be used for many different purposes, for example:

as a formal representation of the constraints of a Dublin Core Application Profile
as configuration for databases
as configuration for metadata editing tools

A DSP does not address the following:

Human-readable documentation.
Definition of vocabularies.
Version control.

A DSP contains the formal syntactic constraints only, and will need to be combined with human-readable information, usage guidelines, version management, etc. in order to be used as an application profile. However, the design of the DSP information model is intended to facilitate the merging of DSP information and external information of the above kinds, for example by tools generating human-readable documentation for a Dublin Core Application Profile.

A Dublin Core Application Profile is a document, or set of documents, that puts a Description Set Profile into a broader context of Functional Requirements, Domain Models, guidelines on syntax and usage, and possibly data formats. See the Singapore Framework for Dublin Core Application Profiles for the broader picture.

2. Basic structure

A DSP describes the structure of a Description Set by using the notions of "templates" and "constraints". A template describes the possible metadata structures in a conforming record.

There are two levels of templates in a Description Set Profile:

Description templates , which contain the statement templates that apply to a single kind of description as well as constraints on the described resource.
Statement templates , which contain all the constraints on the property, value strings, vocabulary encoding schemes, etc. that apply to a single kind of statement.

While templates are used to express structures, constraints are used to limit those structures. The following figure depicts the basic elements of the structure.

3. Basic semantics

The fundamental usage model for a DSP is to examine whether a metadata record matches the DSP.

Matching of a description set is defined as follows:

Binding of descriptions to description templates: Each description is bound to a Description Template by evaluating the Resource Constraint of each Description Template against the described resource. Each description must be bound to exactly one Description Template.
Binding of statements to statement templates: For each description, each statement is bound to a Statement Template in the corresponding Description Template by evaluating the Property Constraint. Each statement must be bound to exactly one Statement Template.
Evaluating constraints: Now that all metadata in the description set has been bound to a template, all constraints can be verified.

4. Usage examples

4.1. Example 1: Constraining the resource

The following DSP matches descriptions with a single resource. The resource must be an instance of foaf:Person.

<?xml version="1.0" ?>

<DescriptionSetTemplate xmlns="http://dublincore.org/xml/dc-dsp/2008/03/31" >

  <DescriptionTemplate ID="person" minOccurs="1" maxOccurs="1" standalone="yes">
    
    <ResourceClass>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Person</ResourceClass>

  </DescriptionTemplate>

</DescriptionSetTemplate>

As it stands, this DSP does not allow for the description of that resource to contain any statements, so it is not very useful.

4.2. Example 2: Constraining a property

The following DSP adds a mandatory foaf:name property with a literal value to the previous example.

<?xml version="1.0" ?>

<DescriptionSetTemplate xmlns="http://dublincore.org/xml/dc-dsp/2008/03/31">

  <DescriptionTemplate ID="person" minOccurs="1" maxOccurs="1" standalone="yes">
    
   <ResourceClass>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Person</ResourceClass>

    <StatementTemplate minOccurs="1" maxOccurs="1" type="literal">

      <Property>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name</Property>

    </StatementTemplate>

  </DescriptionTemplate>

</DescriptionSetTemplate>

4.3. Example 3: Constraining the value

The following DSP constrains the value to be a literal without a language.

<?xml version="1.0" ?>

<DescriptionSetTemplate xmlns="http://dublincore.org/xml/dc-dsp/2008/03/31">

  <DescriptionTemplate ID="person" minOccurs="1" maxOccurs="1" standalone="yes">
    
    <ResourceClass>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Person</ResourceClass>

    <StatementTemplate minOccurs="1" maxOccurs="1" type="literal">

      <Property>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name</Property>

      <LiteralConstraint>
        <LanguageOccurrence>disallowed</LanguageOccurrence>

      </LiteralConstraint>

    </StatementTemplate>

  </DescriptionTemplate>

</DescriptionSetTemplate>

4.4. Example 4: Two resources

The following DSP allows for two kinds of resources: a single "document", and multiple "authors". The Person resources may only occur as values of the dcterms:creator property, not stand-alone. The value may only be described in a separate description with a mandatory foaf:name property.

<?xml version="1.0" ?>

<DescriptionSetTemplate xmlns="http://dublincore.org/xml/dc-dsp/2008/03/31">

  <DescriptionTemplate ID="document" minOccurs="1" maxOccurs="1" standalone="yes">

    <ResourceClass>http://purl.org/dc/terms/Text</ResourceClass>

    <StatementTemplate minOccurs="1" type="nonliteral">

      <Property>http://purl.org/dc/terms/creator</Property>

      <NonLiteralConstraint descriptionTemplateID="person">
        <ValueURIOccurrence>disallowed</ValueURIOccurrence>
        <VocabularyEncodingSchemeOccurrence>disallowed</VocabularyEncodingSchemeOccurrence>
        <ValueStringConstraint maxOccur="0"/>

      </NonLiteralConstraint>

    </StatementTemplate>

  </DescriptionTemplate>

  <DescriptionTemplate ID="person" standalone="no">
    
    <ResourceClass>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Person</ResourceClass>

    <StatementTemplate minOccurs="1" maxOccurs="1" type="literal">

      <Property>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name</Property>

      <LiteralConstraint>
        <LanguageOccurrence>disallowed</LanguageOccurrence>

      </LiteralConstraint>

    </StatementTemplate>

  </DescriptionTemplate>

</DescriptionSetTemplate>

5. Description Templates

A description Template has the following attributes.

XML Element Name: DescriptionTemplate

5.1. Identifier

Summary: A string that can be used in a Value Constraint to reference a description template that applies to the value resource.
Allowed values: A valid XML ID string.
Default: N/A
XML Attribute Name: ID

5.2. Standalone

Summary: Whether descriptions matching this template are allowed to occur standalone, i.e. without being the value of a property.
Allowed values: "yes" / "no" / "both"
Default: "both"
Conditions: If standalone is "yes", a matching description may not be a description of value occurring elsewhere in the DSP.
If standalone is "no", a matching description *must* be a description of value occurring elsewhere in the DSP.
If standalone is "both", both are allowed.
If this description template is referred to in a Value Constraint, standalone cannot be "yes".
XML Attribute Name: standalone

5.3. Minimum occurrence constraint

Summary: The minimum number of times this kind of description must appear in the Description Set.
Allowed values: non-negative integer
Default: 0
Conditions: must be equal or less than the Maximum occurrence
XML Attribute Name: minOccurs

5.4. Maximum occurrence constraint

Summary: The maximum number of times this kind of description is allowed to appear in the Description Set.
Allowed values: non-negative integer or "infinity"
Default: "infinity"
Conditions: must be equal or greater than the Minimum occurrence
XML Attribute Name: maxOccurs

5.5. Resource Class Membership Constraint

Summary: Classes that the resource may be an instance of
Allowed values: a list of class URIs
Default: no constraint
Conditions: if given, the resource must be an instance of one of the given classes.
XML Element Name: ResourceClass

6. Statement templates

A statement template has the following possible constraints.

XML Element Name: StatementTemplate

6.1. Minimum occurrence constraint

Summary: The minimum number of times this kind of statement must appear in the enclosing Description.
Allowed values: non-negative integer
Default: 0
Conditions: must be equal or less than the Maximum occurrence
XML Attribute Name: minOccurs

6.2. Maximum occurrence constraint

Summary: The maximum number of times this kind of statement is allowed to appear in the enclosing Description.
Allowed values: non-negative integer or "infinity"
Default: "infinity"
Conditions: must be equal or greater than the Minimum occurrence
XML Attribute Name: maxOccurs

6.3. Type constraint

Summary: The type of value surrogate (literal/non-literal) that is allowed in this Statement.
Allowed values: "literal" / "nonliteral"
Default: both allowed
Conditions: If no value is given, no further constraining on the value surrogate can be made.
XML Attribute Name: type

Note: that the type constraint should follow any range given for the used properties.

6.4. Property constraints

There are two ways of constraining the property in a statement: - By giving an explicit list of allowed properties

By requiring the property to be a sub-property of a given property.

Exactly one of the above methods must be used in a single statement template.

6.4.1. Property list constraint

Summary: A set of properties that are allowed in this statement template.
Allowed values: a list of property URIs
Default: N/A
Conditions: cannot occur together with a sub-property constraint
XML Element Name: Property

6.4.2. Sub-property constraint

Summary: Only sub-properties of the given property are allowed in this statement template. Note that the given property is included in this list (all properties are sub-properties of themselves).
Allowed values: a property URI
Default: N/A
Conditions: cannot occur together with a property list constraint
XML Element Name: SubPropertyOf

6.5. Literal value constraints

Constrains a literal value surrogate in a statement. Only allowed in the case that the type constraint has the value "literal".

XML Element Name: LiteralConstraint

6.5.1. Literal list constraint

Summary: Literals that are allowed as values.
Allowed values: a list of literals, i.e. (string, language tag) or (string, syntax encoding scheme URI) pairs.
Default: no constraint
Conditions: if given, no other literal constraint may be given
XML Element Name: LiteralOption

6.5.2. Literal language constraint

Summary: Whether languages are allowed for the literal
Allowed values: "mandatory" / "optional" / "disallowed"
Default: "optional"
Conditions: if "mandatory", Syntax encoding schemes are automatically disallowed.
XML Element Name: LanguageOccurrence

Summary: Languages allowed for the literal
Allowed values: a list consisting of language tags
Default: no constraint
XML Element Name: Language

6.5.4. Syntax Encoding Scheme constraint

Summary: Whether Syntax Encoding Scheme are allowed for the literal
Allowed values: "mandatory" / "optional" / "disallowed"
Default: "optional"
Conditions: if "mandatory", language tags are automatically disallowed.
XML Element Name: SyntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence

6.5.5. Syntax Encoding Scheme list constraint

Summary: Syntax encoding schemes allowed for the literal
Allowed values: a list consisting of syntax encoding scheme URIs
Default: no constraint
XML Element Name: SyntaxEncodingScheme

6.6. Non-literal value constraints

Constrains the value surrogate in a statement. Only allowed in the case that the type constraint has the value "nonliteral".

XML Element Name: NonLiteralConstraint

6.6.1. Description template reference

Summary: A reference to a description template that may be used to describe the value
Allowed values: an identifier defined in a Description Template
Default: Related description not allowed
Conditions: if given, any related description of the value within the record must match the referenced Description Template. If the referenced Description Template contains mandatory Statement templates, such a description of the value must exist.
XML Attribute Name: descriptionTemplateRef

6.6.2. Class membership constraint

Summary: Classes that the value may be an instance of
Allowed values: a list of class URIs
Default: no constraint
Conditions: if given, the value must be an instance of one of the given classes.
XML Element Name: ValueClass

Note: this is not a syntactic constraint, and as such might not be evaluated by all processors. If a type statement is desired, an explicit Statement template in a Description Template for the value resource should be created.

6.6.3. Value URI constraint

6.6.3.1. Value URI occurrence constraint

Summary: Whether a value URI must be given
Allowed values: "disallowed" / "optional" / "mandatory"
Default: "optional"
Conditions
XML Element Name: ValueURIOccurrence

6.6.3.2. Value URI list constraint

Summary: URIs that are allowed as value URIs.
Allowed values: a list of URIs
Default: no constraint
Conditions: If a value URI is given, it must be taken from this list. Cannot be specified if value occurrence is "disallowed"
XML Element Name: ValueURI

6.6.4. Vocabulary encoding scheme constraint

6.6.4.1. Vocabulary encoding scheme occurrence constraint

Summary: Whether a vocabulary encoding scheme must be given
Allowed values: "disallowed" / "optional" / "mandatory"
Default: "optional"
Conditions
XML Element Name: VocabularyEncodingSchemeOccurrence

6.6.4.2. Vocabulary encoding scheme list constraint

Summary: URIs that are allowed as Vocabulary Encoding schemes.
Allowed values: a list of URIs
Default: no constraint
Conditions: If a vocabulary encoding scheme is given, it must be taken from this list. Cannot be specified if vocabulary encoding scheme occurrence is "disallowed"
XML Element Name: VocabularyEncodingScheme

6.6.5. Value String Constraints

If at least one value string constraint is given, any value string must match at least one of the constraints. If no value string constraint is given, any value string is allowed.

For each value string constraint, the following may be specified.

XML Element Name: ValueStringConstraint

6.6.5.1. Minimum occurrence constraint

Summary: The minimum number of times this kind of value string must appear in the enclosing Statement.
Allowed values: non-negative integer
Default: 0
Conditions: must be equal or less than the Maximum occurrence
XML Attribute Name: minOccurs

6.6.5.2. Maximum occurrence constraint

Summary: The maximum number of times this kind of value string is allowed to appear in the enclosing Statement.
Allowed values: non-negative integer or "infinity"
Default: "infinity"
Conditions: must be equal or greater than the Minimum occurrence
XML Attribute Name: maxOccurs

6.6.5.3. Other constraints

All Literal value constraints (section 6.5) can be used for value strings as well.

7. XML structure

<?xml version="1.0" ?>

<DescriptionSetTemplate>

  <DescriptionTemplate standalone="" ID="" minOccurs="" maxOccurs="">

    <ResourceClass></ResourceClass>

    <ResourceClass></ResourceClass>

    <StatementTemplate ID="" minOccurs="" maxOccurs="" type="">

      <Property></Property>
      <Property></Property>

      <SubPropertyOf></SubPropertyOf>

      <NonliteralConstraint descriptionTemplateRef="">

        <ValueClass></ValueClass>
        <ValueClass></ValueClass>

        <ValueURIOccurrence></ValueURIOccurrence>

        <ValueURI></ValueURI>
        <ValueURI></ValueURI>

        <VocabularyEncodingSchemeOccurrence></VocabularyEncodingSchemeOccurrence>

        <VocabularyEncodingScheme></VocabularyEncodingScheme>
        <VocabularyEncodingScheme></VocabularyEncodingScheme>

        <ValueStringConstraint minOccurs="" maxOccurs="">
          <LiteralOption lang="" SES=""></LiteralOption>

          <LiteralOption lang="" SES=""></LiteralOption>

          <LanguageOccurrence></LanguageOccurrence>

          <Language></Language>
          <Language></Language>

          <SyntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence></SyntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence>

          <SyntaxEncodingScheme></SyntaxEncodingScheme>
          <SyntaxEncodingScheme></SyntaxEncodingScheme>   

        </ValueStringConstraint>

      </NonLiteralConstraint>

      <LiteralConstraint>
          <LiteralOption lang="" SES=""></LiteralOption>
          <LiteralOption lang="" SES=""></LiteralOption>

          <LanguageOccurrence></LanguageOccurrence>

          <Language></Language>
          <Language></Language>

          <SyntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence></SyntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence>

          <SyntaxEncodingScheme></SyntaxEncodingScheme>

          <SyntaxEncodingScheme></SyntaxEncodingScheme>   

      </LiteralConstraint>

    </StatementTemplate>

  </DescriptionTemplate>

</DescriptonSetTemplate>

8. RDF variant

<?xml version="1.0"?>
<rdf:RDF xmlns:rdf="http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#"
         xmlns:dsp="http://purl.org/dc/dsp/">

  <dsp:DescriptionTemplate rdf:about="#d1">
    <dsp:standalone rdf:datatype="xsd:boolean">true</dsp:standalone>

    <dsp:minOccur rdf:datatype="xsd:nonNegativeInteger">0</dsp:minOccur>
    <dsp:maxOccur rdf:datatype="xsd:nonNegativeInteger">0</dsp:maxOccur>

    <dsp:resourceClass rdf:resource=""/>
    <dsp:resourceClass rdf:resource=""/>

    <dsp:statementTemplate>
      <dsp:LiteralStatementTemplate>
        <dsp:minOccur rdf:datatype="xsd:nonNegativeInteger">0</dsp:minOccur>
        <dsp:maxOccur rdf:datatype="xsd:nonNegativeInteger">0</dsp:maxOccur>

        <dsp:property rdf:resource=""/>
        <dsp:property rdf:resource=""/>

        <dsp:subPropertyOf rdf:resource=""/>

        <dsp:literalConstraint>
          <dsp:LiteralConstraint>

            <dsp:literal xml:lang="" rdf:datatype=""></dsp:literal>
            <dsp:literal xml:lang="" rdf:datatype=""></dsp:literal>
         
            <dsp:languageOccurrence rdf:datatype="dsp:occurrence"></dsp:languageOccurrence>

            <dsp:language rdf:datatype="xsd:language"></dsp:language>

            <dsp:language rdf:datatype="xsd:language"></dsp:language>

            <dsp:syntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence rdf:datatype="dsp:occurrence"></dsp:syntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence>

            <dsp:syntaxEncodingScheme rdf:resource=""/>
            <dsp:syntaxEncodingScheme rdf:resource=""/>

          </dsp:LiteralConstraint>
        </dsp:literalConstraint>
      </dsp:LiteralStatementTemplate>
    </dsp:statementTemplate>

    <dsp:statementTemplate>
      <dsp:NonLiteralStatementTemplate>

         <dsp:nonLiteralConstraint>
          <dsp:NonLiteralConstraint>

            <dsp:descriptionTemplate rdf:resource=""/>

            <dsp:valueClass rdf:resource=""/>
            <dsp:valueClass rdf:resource=""/>

            <dsp:valueURIOccurrence rdf:datatype="dsp:occurrence"></dsp:valueURIOccurrence>
            
            <dsp:valueURI rdf:datatype="xsd:URI"></dsp:valueURI>
            <dsp:valueURI rdf:datatype="xsd:URI"></dsp:valueURI>

            <dsp:vocabularyEncodingSchemeOccurrence rdf:datatype="dsp:occurrence"></dsp:vocabularyEncodingSchemeOccurrence>

            <dsp:vocabularyEncodingScheme rdf:resource=""/>
            <dsp:vocabularyEncodingScheme rdf:resource=""/>

            <dsp:valueStringConstraint>
              <dsp:ValueStringConstraint>

                <dsp:minOccur rdf:datatype="xsd:nonNegativeInteger">0</dsp:minOccur>

                <dsp:maxOccur rdf:datatype="xsd:nonNegativeInteger">0</dsp:maxOccur>

                <dsp:literal xml:lang="" rdf:datatype=""></dsp:literal>
                <dsp:literal xml:lang="" rdf:datatype=""></dsp:literal>
         
                <dsp:languageOccurrence rdf:datatype="dsp:occurrence"></dsp:languageOccurrence>

                <dsp:language rdf:datatype="xsd:language"></dsp:language>
                <dsp:language rdf:datatype="xsd:language"></dsp:language>

                <dsp:syntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence rdf:datatype="dsp:occurrence"></dsp:syntaxEncodingSchemeOccurrence>

                <dsp:syntaxEncodingScheme rdf:resource=""/>

                <dsp:syntaxEncodingScheme rdf:resource=""/>

              </dsp:ValueStringConstraint>
            </dsp:valueStringConstraint>
          </dsp:NonLiteralConstraint>
        </dsp:nonLiteralConstraint>
      </dsp:NonLiteralStatementTemplate>

    </dsp:statementTemplate>
  </dsp:DescriptionTemplate>
</rdf:RDF>

9. Examples

9.1 "Simple" Dublin Core

<?xml version="1.0" ?>

<DescriptionSetTemplate xmlns="http://dublincore.org/xml/dc-dsp/2008/03/31">

  <DescriptionTemplate>

    <StatementTemplate>
      <Property>http://purl.org/dc/terms/title</Property>
    </StatementTemplate>

    <StatementTemplate>
      <Property>http://purl.org/dc/terms/creator</Property>
    </StatementTemplate>

   <!-- etc -->

  </DescriptionTemplate>

</DescriptionSetTemplate>

9.2 Simple FOAF

<?xml version="1.0" ?>

<DescriptionSetTemplate xmlns="http://dublincore.org/xml/dc-dsp/2008/03/31">

  <DescriptionTemplate ID="person" minOccur="1" maxOccur="1">
    
    <ResourceClass>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Person</ResourceClass>

    <StatementTemplate minOccurs="1" maxOccurs="1" type="literal">

      <Property>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name</Property>

    </StatementTemplate>

    <StatementTemplate type="nonliteral">

      <Property>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/knows</Property>

      <NonLiteralConstraint descriptionTemplateRef="person">

        <ValueClass>http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Person</ValueClass>

      </NonLiteralConstraint>

    </StatementTemplate>

   <!-- etc -->

  </DescriptionTemplate>

</DescriptionSetTemplate>

2014-10-26: See also dcmi-dsp.xsd.